Anna Jo Christopher from the December 8, 2014 issue
Penny hadn't even met the new guy on the street, but that didn't stop her neighbors from making plans...
In a Nutshell
The ladies of the homeowners association where Penny lives tries to set her up with the man who just moved in.
I don't recall reading a group matchmaker story before--at least not recently. That was a twist on the trope, but other than that, this was an average story. Neither the characters nor their conversation was particularly engaging, but I really liked the ending line.
I may never know which matchmaking board member stuck the flyer in Drew's door, but it doesn't matter--at our next meeting, I'm voting to re-elect all of them!