Monday, October 27, 2025

A Pizza Party 'Plus One'

by Jennifer Anne F. Messing from the September 29, 2025 issue

Tagline: When Cerise Campbell hosts her daughter's birthday, handsome single dad Jordan steps in to help...and love is on the menu.

Stream of Consciousness Observations: "They turned onto Iris Lane, which was shaded by trees with leaves in brilliant fall colors." -- I'm interested to see if there's a reason the street is specifically named.

"Oh no!" Macie wailed. "Who will deliver our pizzas?" -- This sounds a tiny bit stilted, especially coming from the mouth of a teen.

Oooh, stovetop popcorn is the BEST.

As he picked up one of the big bowls of popcorn [sic] his strong, muscular arm brushed against Cherise's arm and she felt an unexpected, pleasant tingle in her arm. -- This is an example of why reading your story aloud is a good idea. The word arm is used three times, which is, if you ask me, one too many.

Nice story! I especially liked the laid-back plans for the birthday party. These days with Instagram and Pinterest, I feel like so many people feel pressure to dial up their events. Birthdays should be celebrated, but not all of them require photo-inspired fanfare.

Photo by Andrew Rivett via Flickr CC License

4 comments:

Sandy Smith said...

Cute story. But I couldn't figure out why the delivery driver shortage was such a dilemma, especially if the pizza place was just around the corner. The mom could have gone to pick them up.

Kate Willoughby said...

I agree, Sandy, but I wondered if she felt uncomfortable leaving the girls alone. Either way, it didn't bother me all that much.

Anonymous said...

How did that "arm" repetition get by the editors?

Kate Willoughby said...

I have no idea, Anonymous!