Tagline: After years of loneliness, Jessie had given up on love--then she met Christopher...
This was my story and I've always enjoyed showing you the before and after so you can see an example of what editors actually do. Words in blue were added by the editor.
You'll see there was quite a bit of work done. I can see that the bit about divorced women was removed, which doesn't surprise me. Why go the "negative" route when it's not necessary? In fact, many of the tweaks were in that vein. It's funny how I preach that in my class, but failed to follow my own suggestion. LOL
You'll also see the story was firmly planted in the April, so that it would connect with the time of year the story was hitting the stands.
At the risk of insulting the editor, I will say the ending didn't sing for me. I prefer it where it's is eagerness and joy that we're left with, instead of her soft reply. I think it's the word "soft" that bothers me. I think if she'd smiled or cocked her head or something, it wouldn't have felt so shy to me. However, in hindsight, I really should have written something in the first place that tied in with the theme of flowers and spring and blooming. Again, this is a tip I give in my class--to really, really work on the endings so that they are superb. I seem to have gotten a little lazy here. LOL
“You can’t believe
everything you read have to keep trying,” Allison commented to her co-worker, Jessie, as they made
"Oh, come on, Allison, do you really think I haven't tried? Have you forgotten about that blind date I had last month?”
Allison finished tying a ribbon on the bouquet she was making, then stood up to stretch her legs. made a face. “Month being the operative word…” She trailed off, her attention
suddenly drawn to a car pulling up to the store. “I think "Maybe you should go on the
offense. Make a pass at the Harry Potter guy. someone, or at least show him you’re interested. Like
the Man Wizard. He’s adorable. He doesn’t wear a wedding ring, you know, and he's adorable! Ask him out!. Would
you go out with him if he asked you?”
"I'm so not listening to you," Jessie said, rolling rolled her eyes. Her matchmaking co-worker Allison loved to give nicknames to customers, and one of their most
faithful patrons was Christopher customers had the last name of Potter, who often bought flowers for his mother. Allison had observed that w With
his dark good looks and bookish eyeglasses, he really resembled Christopher Potter was like a hunky and grown up, hunky Harry Potter.
Allison continued. “He
likes the beach. You both like the beach. He likes to travel and so do you. You both
love Thai food... and Monday night football. Need I say more? go on?”
"That's true," Jessie said. "We do have a lot in common, or so it seems, but All
that was true. She and Christopher had chatted often. They did have a lot in
common.
“Good
customers, you we have. It's a boyfriend you want." a lot of. Boyfriends? Not so much.”
The April showers had stopped, and the sun was coming out as an elegant-looking woman got out of her car and approached the shop. Just then, the The
phone rang and Jessie went to answer it while Allison greeted the customer.
“Welcome to Flowers by Jessie," Allison said, ". How can I help you?”
“Welcome to Flowers by Jessie," Allison said, "
The
woman smiled. “I’d like to send something to my son for his birthday. But do
you have something a little more masculine than a bouquet?”
Allison
showed her some of the miniature bonsai trees and the woman loved them.
“I believe this is something my son would like, and I want I’d like this to
be delivered to him around six p.m. by Jessie. I’ll even pay extra for that if necessary if I need
to, but it needs to be her.” At Allison’s quizzical look, the woman added: conspiratorially, “My son has given buys me flowers every single month, ever since his father my
husband passed away, and he’s always talking about his florist, Jessie, and how pretty
she is and I thought it would make his day for her to deliver them in person." , as a mother, it was my duty to…”
A
sudden suspicion bloomed in Allison’s mind as she got ready to record the necessary information into the computer. brain. “If I could have your name
please?”
“Deborah
Potter. My son is Christopher Potter, and he lives at 105 Oak Lane.”
A
few days later, Jessie pulled up at to Christopher Potter’s house with the bonsai tree on the seat next to her. Allison usually did the afternoon deliveries, but she practically pushed Jessie out the door, saying it was her big chance with Harry Potter. She was more nervous
than she had a right to be. Christopher Potter was a sweet guy who obviously
loved his mother a lot. He was funny and handsome and single. Whether he was
attracted to her remained a question. She told herself to remain professional as
she rang the doorbell. This was just an everyday delivery.
When Christopher opened the door, her heart accelerated.
"Jessie!" He grinned. "What a nice surprise!"Christopher’s
eyes widened in surprise. “Jessie?”
"Jessie!" He grinned. "What a nice surprise!"
“You’re
kidding. Wow, and it's really great to see you again!" thanks.”
Another car drove up and a teenaged boy jumped outas he read the card. A kid got out
holding a couple of bags. As he got closer, Jessie got a whiff of something
yummy.
Another car drove up and a teenaged boy jumped out
“I have an order for Jessie and Christopher," he said. Order for
Jessie?”
“I’m Jessie," she said.”
"I'm Christopher," he echoed, reaching for his wallet.
"I'm Christopher," he echoed, reaching for his wallet.
“Allison from the flower shop," the boy called out while rushing back to his car.”
Christopher
chuckled. “It smells great. I love the Thai Kitchen.”
Jessie shook her head. “You realize
what’s going on right?”
His eyes twinkled.
“Sure. My Hmmm...my mom and your friend think we need to spend the evening together
eating eat Thai food together while and chatting about miniature potted trees.”
She couldn’t help
laughing. “I’m really sorry about this," she said. .”
Jessie's heart fluttered as Christopher He gazed down at
her with his and she suddenly felt quite small and feminine. He had the most gorgeous
brown eyes. and a smile like a warm hug. "I'm not!"
16 comments:
A very nice little story, Kate, but that is indeed an eye opener. I know, when reading another's story, it is a great temptation to practically rewrite it for them. The WW editor in this case really let herself go, didn't she?
Well, they published your idea and you got paid for it. I just got a note from Patricia last night, saying she liked my story but the EIC rejected it. That is the second time within the month.
Hi, Kate,
I was confused when I first saw this title. I remember you publishing another version of "Love in Bloom" on your blog when it got rejected. I see that you revised it... I was curious as to how to handle this. Did you mention to Patricia Gaddis that you had previously submitted it but rewrote it? Since it's basically the same idea and same title, I was wondering what you did. Thanks very much! It was a cute story, BTW! :)
After reading Anon's comment I found your other story too, Kate. It does seem to be the same story, which brings up something I've always been confused about. When does a story become a different story for 'copyright' purposes? Is it only after a minor change? A lot of change? I was once told its when the story isn't recognisable any more. If that's not the case, I'd love to know for sure.
CD
Kate, don't quite understand. This is your story under a different name? Mary Jo, did you get the note from Patty by email or postal mail? I thought we would hear nothing unless our stories were accepted. I don't think the new guidelines mentioned how our contracts would be delivered--by email or postal mail.
Tamara, it was just a very brief email from Patricia. I greatly appreciated that she took the time to let me know why the story was rejected, rather than just never hearing anything.
Are you sure this is the same story Kate presented before? I thought WW would not look at a story more than once. It might be that so many of their published stories are so similar, it is easy to think you have read them before. I do recall another story where the girl took a Banzai tree to the man's house. Was that Kate's?
I think so much more could be done with that little Romance page, but Patricia and the EIC may not see eye to eye.
Kate, I reread your original, although rejected, "Love in Bloom" story (you posted it May 29, 2012.) It was very similar. Glad to know that it's OK to rewrite a rejected story and resubmit down the road. Did you indicate that on your cover letter? Thanks so much, this blog is wonderful is incredibly helpful! You are so talented! :)
I personally think it probably is okay to rewrite a previously rejected story and resend, as Kate has done. (although in the past it was a 'no-no'). With this story it's a little different in that Kate has already 'published' her original story on this blog. The WW contract asks that any submissions have not been previously published, so that's why I'd love to know if the changes from Kate's first rejected story and the very similar now published story in WW has enough changes to make it pass the 'not previously been published test'. I'm guessing it has, since the story was accepted?
Lots of interesting questions posed here. Will look forward to Kate's replies.
I enjoyed the story very much. It is interesting to see how it was edited.
I also find it interesting that Patricia is the fiction editor but apparently doesn't have a lot of clout with what stories should be published. That is too bad.
I would expect it takes some time for the EIC and a new editor to get to trust each other with working for what is best for their magazine.
I also wonder what can make a previously published blog story considered "unpublished" as a new submission. I withdrew one story because it had appeared in a blog. It was one of my favorites, though, and I would love to see it in WW.
Aw, Mary Jo. Sorry about the rejection.
Regarding the resubmission...I totally forgot that I put that story up here. Well, that's water under the bridge. But I DID tell Patricia that I had pulled that out of my archive of rejected stories and she was fine with it. My thought was maybe Johnene didn't like some of those stories, but maybe Patricia did.
Regarding how much change does a story have to go through in order to not violate copyright? I have no idea. Sorry. :(
Tamara, Kim Winklhofer is my real name.
Resending old stories used to be a no-no, but because there's a new woman at the helm, I think that gives us some leeway. However, I wouldn't go sending ALL your rejected stories. Pick the best ones, the ones you really think should have made the cut.
I agree, Kate. Patricia seems to be very writer friendly, so let's all try to give her our best.
I'm thinking the ones rejected by Johnene were selected by Patricia in the first place, so they may be worth a try. I found one that no one had seen except Jimmy Meiss, so off it went. Kate, how did you come to use a second name?
Kate, thanks for posting your submission with the edits. What a great job Patricia did with your story. I love her edits and it showed me so much about what WW wants in a story.
Congrats on the sale.
That was a cute story, Kate! I liked seeing the edits.
I remembered reading somewhere that it was okay to re-submit a story after six months—did I dream that?
I also understood that if your story was rejected, you didn't hear back. It is nice to hear something one way or the other.
Thanks for sharing the version with the edits, Kate! As someone said above, it's too bad the fiction editor doesn't seem to have much clout.
Tamara, I used Kate Willoughby originally for my steamy stuff because I was a substitute teacher when I started, so I thought parents might not appreciate the fact that I was writing novels with graphic sex. As for going with my real name this time, I just felt like changing it up.
Thanks, Pat.
Mary, Before the Retirement, you could resubmit a story if you hadn't heard in 6 months. Now, if you don't hear after 4 months you are to assume it was rejected.
Post a Comment